TexasCHLforum.com

Well, let's face it folks, we will never know the true effectiveness of any particular round in this 'real' world.

All of the studies using wet newspaper, ballistic gelatin with and without fabric covering, discussions of ballistic physics, barrell length, bullet weight, powder choice is all theoretical for most of us.

It is all like kicking the tires on a car to determine if those are "good tires" or not.

Until we can convince some aggressive, hyped-up volunteers to line up and be shot we can never know what the true effectiveness on our ammo selection will be compared to another choice. Even then, we would have to compare the effect of shot placement in the equation.

Essentially, having something is going to be more effective than having nothing when the critical moment presents itself. On the otherhand, having a hand cannon and putting the shot in the wrong place will be less effective than putting a .380 in the right place.

My decision making process on this issue has eventually evolved to the following. I read some, listen to others some, make sure the choice works 100% in the weapon, and make a decision and don't worry or over analyze my selection. If you feel comfortable with what you use stay with it. If you like having the 'latest technology', that is OK too...repeat the process.

Afterwards, PRACTICE, PRACTICE, PRACTICE!! Whether this involves a formal training process, IDPA or IPSC type competition or whatever, do it to make sure that you can put a round in the right spot in a time of stress while you move. Better yet, occasionally practice doing this in a low/no light situation while holding a flashlight. Probably 70% of civilian self defense situatons using deadly force occur during conditions of low/no light.

All that being said (and while stepping down from form my wobbly soapbox) I will add that my carry choice is a Glock 30 (.45ACP) which has a 3 7/8" barrel with night sights. My ammunition choice for years has been

Corbon 185 gr +P hollowpoint

After reading I have purchased some

Corbon DPX 185 +P hollowpoint.

I am seriously considering a change to this round and will fire enough to satisfy myself as to its flawless operation in my pistol before making a final decision.

For any who might be interested, I did a personal test on a pair of recently killed deer carcases a couple of years ago to test the penetration, and retained mass of my current carry choice. I was VERY impressed. If any would like to read the results let me know.

Good luck out there.