CompVest wrote:It isn't the "qualification test" that is important, it is the practice or lack of practice between tests that is important.
And while we do all (pretty safe to say) agree that training is good, this is part of the reason that no useful effects are seen when comparing significant training/qualification requirements such as Texas against no requirements in New Hampshire and Washington, or even no license in required in Vermont and Alaska.People who choose to carry legally are usually going to take steps to become competent -- those that won't are irresponsible no matter what the law requires for "licensing", and that includes police officers who do the bare minimum AND don't retain their competence.
Lately CarolM and I have been watching "The Academy" reality TV of the LA Sheriff's Office Police Academy -- it's enlightening to see where the people (not just kids either) start. In firearms, their problems aren't too surprising, but also in just getting around in life they are frequently barely competent.
Of course the show probably concentrates on 'problem' cases as they are more interesting than the young men and women who are just quietly competent and able to learn what is taught.