TexasCHLforum.com

G26ster wrote:

Trilogy wrote:I believe that the popularity of the .45acp comes from the old military issued firearms. I talk to the guys at my local VFW hall regularly and .45 is still the preferred caliber for most vets. I prefer the combination of the ballistics and magazine capacity of he .40 s&w. On average, 92% of the power of the .45 but twice the magazine capacity. If the need to use my carry gun presents itself, nothing like a few extra rounds to make sure I don't have to reload.

I think the comparison of military use and civilian self defense use of the .45 pistol is quite different. When it comes to to the "effectiveness" of the .45 in combat, in 1941 the U.S. Army R&D section had a pretty dim view of the .45 after WWI (which was an up close and personal war) when they published the following:

“This weapon (the M1911) was primarily for defensive purposes since its effective range is limited to not more than 25 yards, except when handled by an expert. Its ineffectiveness was well proven by the amazingly small number of casualties it inflicted upon enemy troops during WWI as revealed by post-war inspection of German casualty lists and hospital records.”

Now again, I believe most civilian self defense encounters occur well within 25 yards, and the statement above might not apply. But the statement illustrates that pistols in military combat (at least in WWI) didn't inflict a whole lot of damage, regardless of caliber. If I were in combat again, my vote would be for a pistol that was the most accurate, with an acceptable caliber and capacity, not just caliber alone. The 1911s I carried in the military were usually old, worn, rattled, and far from the accuracy of modern 1911s. Your experience, and the vets at the VFW might be different though. Just MHO.

jmra wrote:

nyj wrote:Nice to see the 9mm love.

means more .40 on the shelf for me.

krieghoff wrote:Give it a try Trakinpat. Ya never know, she might like it and then you might have a shooting partner. Years ago in my younger days, I did just that. As time progressed, she took up shotguns and had a blast at it. Many times when I was out of town and returned, she would have loaded several buckets of 12 gauge AA's for me. Those were the days!!

krieghoff wrote:[quote I really want to get into reloading, I have a few books on it but it is so darn complicated to just READ, I am a visual learner so I need to see it done many times to grasp, theory is great, but practice makes perfect.

JKTex wrote:I"m always curious and usually don't get an answer, what is the point of a poll like this? I'd bet 90% of us could have told you the top 3, in order, but it seems somewhat irrelevant.

ghostrider wrote:

Why does everyone like Gold Dot so much? I'm not bashing it, I genuinely don't know.

good reputation. Used by many police depts.

Unlike some 'premium' JHPs, these are available (well, not right now, but someday again) as reloading components, so in theory those of us who reload can duplicate the factory loads for a cheaper practice load.

SpringerFan wrote:XDSC9, stuffed with 14 rounds of +p Gold Dot goodness.

jmra wrote:

TrackinPat wrote:.40 all day! :)
I would however like to get a 9mm and a .45 as alternate carries some day.

.40 has always been my goto and is again now that the XDs 45 is out of the rotation.