This! No other gun can compare! You would be crazy to get anything elsecarlson1 wrote:Glock 19!
Seriously, a G19 is a great choice. It was my carry choice until I got its baby brother, the G26. But either of your finalists are fine choices. I would pick the one that felt best in my hand, had the trigger pull I liked and I shot the best. Both are quality, reliable firearms. It boils down to personal preference.