Search found 1 match

by WildBill
Sun Aug 12, 2012 1:55 pm
Forum: Off-Topic
Topic: Who is more American?
Replies: 34
Views: 4574

Re: Who is more American?

The Annoyed Man wrote:
57Coastie wrote:
apostate wrote:I don't think either is American....
Leo Manzano is not an American? Is a Mexican not an American? Is a Canadian not an American? How about a Chilean? Is a naturalized U. S. citizen not an American? What is an American?

The greatest country in the world is almost alone in not having a one-word noun to describe a citizen (or "native" if you will). We "United States Americans" have taken over the continent, North, Central and South, I suppose.

Jim
Seriously Jim, people have been using the term "American" to denote a citizen of the United States of America for at least a century......including liberals. In the context you're using, it would be like using "European" to describe a French citizen, but nobody else uses "American" in that context. It's not cultural chauvinism or jingoistic nationalism. It's just common usage. Nothing more.
In the United States it is common usage, but for others it may not be. While working in Mexico [for three years] nobody ever asked me if I was an "American". They would always ask if I was from the U.S.

Although there was one man that I ran into at a Christmans party, a Mexican who was president of the local labor union, who asked me, "Are you still the only gringo working there?" :smilelol5:

On the other hand, they would never state that they were "Americans". They were proud to be Mexican.

Asking the Mexicans if they were "hispanic" is a whole different story. :mrgreen:

Return to “Who is more American?”