Search found 2 matches

by Excaliber
Fri Jun 20, 2014 12:50 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Pick a 1911: Full size vs. Commander Length
Replies: 25
Views: 6176

Re: Pick a 1911: Full size vs. Commander Length

Charles L. Cotton wrote:Excalibur got me to thinking about light weight Commanders again so I started looking at the usual places, including Budsgunshop.com and suffered a severe case of sticker shock! I guess it's been a while since I bought a 1911.

My routine is to buy a Colt, then take it to Ed Vanden Berg for a Briley barrel, Ed Brown trigger group, grip safety and bushing, and Novak sights. Paying $500 to $700 for the raw material is one thing, but I'm not paying $1,100 for a frame and slide. I wish Caspian still made aluminum frames, but they quit several years ago. They sell a titanium frame at twice the price of carbon or stainless steel and I know a lot of custom pistolsmiths won't work on titanium frames because they are tough on tools. I don't know about Vanden Berg, but I'm not buying a titanium frame anyway.

Oh well, I guess I'll be carrying my "heavy" steel guns.

Chas.
Charles, you may want to take a look at these guns. With these, I don't think you'd need to make all the changes you listed to get a gun that would meet your preferences:

Springfield lightweight champion operator

STI Duty One Lightweight 4.0
by Excaliber
Wed Jun 18, 2014 5:57 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Pick a 1911: Full size vs. Commander Length
Replies: 25
Views: 6176

Re: Pick a 1911: Full size vs. Commander Length

SQLGeek wrote:I'm sure this surprised some of you to see me create a thread about 1911s since I'm more of a combat tupperware type but I have my reasons. I may find myself in the near future being in a place where there will be 10 round magazine limits which is leading me to consider a handgun chambered in .45. In addition to the usual host of polymer pistols, I've also started considering 1911s.

If you were to choose one 1911, would your preference be a full size or commander length gun? I truly can't make up my mind as I see advantages to both. This will probably be both a home defense and IDPA / multi-gun type competition gun. I'd like the option to carry it too but that's of secondary concern.
As a guy who has carried all 3 major lengths (3", 4 1/4" and 5") a lot, if I had to pick just one it would be a lightweight frame commander length like the Kimber Pro Carry. I think it is the best compromise for weight, size, carryability, and shootability. That's the size I carry whenever clothing style allows.

The steel frame commander length has advantages in shootability, but its weight reminds me it's there too much for all day carry. If I didn't mind the weight, I'd carry the 5" - the weight difference between the two steel frame versions is insignificant to me, and the grip is what affects concealability much more than barrel length.

Return to “Pick a 1911: Full size vs. Commander Length”