TexasCHLforum.com

I think this 'test' had some merit (unlike the previous one).

Yes, there were some very limiting factors (shooter able to immediately I.D. carriers by virtue of their headgear, etc). But, the SWAT cop was clearly 'holding back', I thought he performed well and tried to make concessions.

I didn't get a good look at the weaponry provided each 'carrier', but there is a good chance it did not match what each person defending themselves was familiar with. Having to defend yourself with a weapon you've never handled before... might be expected to produce poorer accuracy than normal.

Still, not a bad test overall, IMO.