Since this thread started a friend of mine called me up, said let's go flying and I said sure. We got to Northwest Regional, he pulled out a 172, threw me into the left seat and made me do everything until we landed (and he asked if I wanted to land
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3cca3/3cca3c01ddb3d69bd50d51feb074375ab4b2ae1d" alt="Shocked :shock:"
)
Talk about task saturation and getting thrown into the deep end
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c75b/8c75b5c2a482fae433af620927027fd08a62e9f2" alt="Laughing :lol:"
I will say that simulator time helped immensely, only issue was that I didn't even own rudder pedals for my PC until a couple of years ago so that took some getting used to, especially the somewhat delayed response while taxiing. I was used to it by the time we were going back to park though.
Made me really want to get an ultralight or something to fly off of my own property, if I ever get any. I can't see myself ever flying manned aircraft commercially even though I know I'd be good at it, but I'd definitely enjoy flying for fun.