Search found 5 matches

by BroTyler
Sun Aug 15, 2010 10:56 am
Forum: New to CHL?
Topic: Case Law for study
Replies: 15
Views: 3057

Re: Case Law for study

VMaxer wrote:If you want to scare the heck out of yourself, and how even a good defense attorney can go bad - Google the Harold Fish case. Yikes.
Is there a site tracking his appeals and the impact of changes in Arizona law and their effect on his appeals?

Edit: Disregard. Just found his defense website and found out he was released. Hopefully his new trial will have a much better outcome.
by BroTyler
Wed Aug 11, 2010 2:07 pm
Forum: New to CHL?
Topic: Case Law for study
Replies: 15
Views: 3057

Re: Case Law for study

I appreciate the links. I initially looked on FindLaw (remembered it from my days as a would be pre-law) and only found a few cases. I will try out LexisOne for sure.
by BroTyler
Mon Aug 09, 2010 10:54 pm
Forum: New to CHL?
Topic: Case Law for study
Replies: 15
Views: 3057

Re: Case Law for study

jester wrote:The answer would depend what he means by castle doctrine, because the castle doctrine I know has nothing to do with being in your car. :headscratch
I thought the Castle Doctrine was related to Penal Code, Secion 9, as ammended by SB 378 and similar. http://www.capitol.state.tx.us/tlodocs/ ... 00378F.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Essentially, (regardless of CHL status) you are allowed to defend yourself in your home or vehicle, I thought, which is why I was asking about scenarios immediately outside the vehicle.
by BroTyler
Mon Aug 09, 2010 12:42 pm
Forum: New to CHL?
Topic: Case Law for study
Replies: 15
Views: 3057

Re: Case Law for study

I understand you're not a lawyer, but on sites like these it is always a valid point to repeat. :thumbs2:

I primarily intend to carry while commuting to school, so the only time I can foresee there ever being a need for protection is in event of a breakdown or while at a gas station early in the morning or at night on the way home. Does the Castle Doctrine include times when you're "by" your car or house, such as when you're filling up the car or changing a tire on the side of the road?
by BroTyler
Mon Aug 09, 2010 11:16 am
Forum: New to CHL?
Topic: Case Law for study
Replies: 15
Views: 3057

Case Law for study

Does anyone have any good links to look at that feature cases where lethal self-defense was utilized? Specifically, I'm trying to see for myself whether or not anyone has actually done it and not lost their livelihoods in the civil cases that follow.

I asked it in another thread, but it was off-topic: A pharmacist by the name of Jerome Ersland shot a kid during a robbery. Two kids came in with ski masks on, so he pulled his weapon and shot one in the head. He next gave chase after the second one and, when he didn't get him, returned to the pharmacy, pulled a Judge out of a drawer, and fired a few shots into the already-down offender.

The family on the news screamed that they had a good kid, and he never would have anything like this, etc. Discussions with others have led me to agree that he went way too far when he came back and fired more rounds into an already-disabled BG.

So: If he had just left him alone after the first shot and called the police, do you think he would be acquitted of criminal charges? And are there any circumstances that make it so that a civil case can't be brought against you?

Return to “Case Law for study”