Search found 1 match

by MasterOfNone
Tue Oct 04, 2011 8:58 pm
Forum: Gun and/or Self-Defense Related Political Issues
Topic: Can U.S. legally kill a citizen overseas
Replies: 102
Views: 14383

Re: Can U.S. legally kill a citizen overseas

Cobra Medic wrote:Oh, please. At the moment he was killed he was riding in a car. He wasn't pointing a weapon at the Americans who fired the missiles. He was a probable future threat, no argument there, but he was not an immediate threat. A more realistic domestic example is the gang leader who is connected to the thugs who killed your neighbor but he's miles away from you. So you go to his territory and gun him down because you reasonably believe he might be planning to kill you at some time in the future. That's essentially what America did in Yemen last week.

I'm not denying both the al Qaeda member and the gang member are dirt bags. What I am saying is if the killing in Yemen was moral, then it's moral for American citizens to hunt down and kill violent gang members. It's right for those guys in NM and AZ to ambush drug runners coming in from Mexico. It's good for a parent to go after a pedophile who molested her kid but got off on a technicality. In summary, it's moral to be a vigilante when due process can't (or won't) give you justice.

No double standards. :nono:
By your reasoning, just about every bomb, rocket, or missile we have ever fired at a hostile enemy was unjustified. Every action that was ever taken that was not immediate defense was wrong. That would mean that everything we have ever done on foreign soil was wrong.

Return to “Can U.S. legally kill a citizen overseas”