MechAg94 wrote:KC5AV wrote:The Annoyed Man wrote:Except that it's not a scout rifle, this looks kind of like Mossberg's answer to Ruger's Gunsite Scout. Same barrel length, box magazine fed, flash hider, optics rail, and iron sights. The main difference is the location of the rail.
That was my first thought when I saw one... It really wants to be a Scout.
Do you really think the forward mounted scope is better?
Better? It's more like "another way of doing things" than a "better or worse" thing. In other words, it has its advantages and its disadvantages.
The scout scope has the advantage of generous eye relief, which encourages shooting with both eyes open, which gives better situational awareness, and which brings the sight picture into clear focus very quickly and easily. It's sort of like using an RDS, except it has crosshairs.
On the other hand, it has the
disadvantages of lower magnification, smaller range of magnification between highest and lowest settings on the variable power versions, and they tend to have smaller objective lens diameters which can mean less light gathering ability.
So, for long range work, not as good. But for a quick handy "brush gun" kind of rifle, it's a superior platform.
I like my Ruger scout rifle quite a lot, and I have a nice 1.5-5X32mm Leupold Scout scope on it. I am generally sold on the scout rifle concept. But as some of you may know, I've developed cataracts and I'm at the point where I need all the magnification I can get. I haven't shot the rifle in a while, and the changes to my vision have been fairly radical since I last shot it. I suspect that I will have to convert it to a standard format at some point down the road.
XS Sights makes an extended rail the replaces the one that comes on the rifle. The replacement rail is longer and bridges the length of the receiver, allowing you to mount a regular scope in the traditional position. At the rear, it mounts on the OEM rear sight mount, and incorporates an adjustable rear aperture sight on the rail which replaces the OEM rear sight. Alternatively, the rifle comes with a set of standard Ruger scope mounts.
Purists would argue that the RGS isn't a real scout rifle because the box magazine can't be recharged in place though the top of the receiver, using stripper clips. To me, that's kind of irrelevant. Those same purists would say it really isn't a real scout rifle if the scope isn't forward mounted. Pish tosh.
If I reconfigure mine, there is a Vortex Viper PST 2.5-10x32mm scope with an illuminated FFP milling reticle that I like a lot, that I think would be ideal for this kind of rifle configuration......in which case there wouldn't be much difference between the RGS and the Mossberg MVP.
Is the scout concept better? Not really. Both of these companies set out to accomplish basically the same goal—building a light, compact bolt rifle with tactical features, chambered in proven cartridges.
“Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times.”
― G. Michael Hopf, "Those Who Remain"
#TINVOWOOT