RPB wrote:OldGrumpy wrote:RPB wrote:last I heard, Cornyn supports background checks, ... not sure how he plans to get criminals buying stolen guns from burglarized houses to sign up for them, but ...
Another partial truth. Cornyn supported the inclusion of mental health records, certified by a court, into the present background check system.
So, everyone must sign HIPAA-compliant medical authorizations wait for records check, and criminals and crazies who signed them will be filtered out at the expense of everyone's right to privacy being snipped away bit more.
I just can't see that working. Bob gets out of prison on parole, signs his HIPPA form, buys a stolen gun from Joe the House Burglar ... and learns he failed his background check so he'll pay attention to the gunfree zone sign instead of ignoring it.
Meanwhile, Mary, whose dad passed away 8 years ago saw a doctor for grief counseling and the doctor back then diagnosed depression which she got over 4 years ago, now must wait to get a tool to defend herself from a stalker ex boyfriend turned into a beater/abuser
This so blatantly misrepresents the truth that I can only conclude that you are a liberal. You and I have discussed this before, and you are way off the deep end with this description.
Once again, for the stubborn, the bill that Cornyn supports would alter the
existing background check system to ensure that people
adjudicated and properly judged as mentally incompetent would have those records entered into the NICS. IOW, if a court of law, where you are properly represented by council and judged according to the law, finds that you are mentally incompetent, then that judgment would be entered into NICS. It does not require that anyone applying for the purchase of a weapon undergo a medical records check. Furthermore, the law specifically excludes situations such as you describe. Voluntarily entering a mental facility for grief counseling does not qualify. Being taken to a mental facility against your will does not qualify.
Only a court order gets you in the system and that after all your rights have been preserved. It does not add a HIPAA form to the NICS check.
If you want to have a discussion about whether or not NICS checks are constitutional, then fine. But stop misrepresenting Cornyn's position. And stop making up stuff out of thin air that has no relation to fact. That's what liberals do.