First Holster Disappointment

[jsimmons]

Well, I got a Fobus Rotoholster for my XD, and I'm not happy with it. Lesson learned - adjustable paddle holsters are inadequate most CC situations because the pistol simply hangs out too far..

I'm now looking at Don Hume and Uncle Mike's.

[mrvmax]

To be honest, over the years I have never been satisfied with any inexpensive holster I have owned. All that I have liked are ones that I spent more than $50 on. The cheapest one I liked was the Crossbreed Supertuck. As far as holsters go, you get what you pay for.

[ghostrider]

You may find you'll have to try a bunch of different holsters before finding one that works.

For IWB, this is my preference:
http://www.comp-tac.com/product_info.php?products_id=95" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

For OWB, I've been happy with this (just wish it came in black):
http://www.cheaperthandirt.com/LEG524-33.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

An inexpensive IWB that works well (for me) is this one:
http://www.highnoonholsters.com/Product ... ision.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

[karl]

You may find you'll have to try a bunch of different holsters before finding one that works.

For IWB, this is my preference:
http://www.comp-tac.com/product_info.php?products_id=95" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Helpful link, I'm going to be buying one soon and I had a question for you. Which do you prefer, C-clips or standard? Thanks.

[ghostrider]

I use the standard clips.

[chamberc]

Well, I got a Fobus Rotoholster for my XD, and I'm not happy with it. Lesson learned - adjustable paddle holsters are inadequate most CC situations because the pistol simply hangs out too far..

I'm now looking at Don Hume and Uncle Mike's.

Join the club, we all have boxes of bad holsters...

I finally broke down and ordered a super tuck deluxe from CrossBreedHolsters.com just today... says I'll get it in 2-3 weeks. Many people on the board report good luck and the Guntalk guy loves them.

[jsimmons]

I've ordered a Don Hume 721OT. We'll see...

[timdsmith72]

You may find you'll have to try a bunch of different holsters before finding one that works.

For IWB, this is my preference:
http://www.comp-tac.com/product_info.php?products_id=95" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Helpful link, I'm going to be buying one soon and I had a question for you. Which do you prefer, C-clips or standard? Thanks.

I use the C clips. They work just fine.

[jsimmons]

I got my 721 OT today. I have to wait till I get home to try the pistol in it though.

[ferretray]

Cheap, ain't.
Save your $ and invest in a decent quality holster/belt. Check out the FIST website and prices.

[Harley rider 55]

I've ordered a Don Hume 721OT. We'll see...

The Hume 721OT is an excellent value in a non-custom OWB holster. I carry my sig P239 in one and it's the first holster I bought for it.
IWB comfort will require a little searching as body types differ. I've heard of 1 or 2 custom holster makers that will let you try their product and send it back for a refund if it doesn't work for you. The biggest problem is the established master holster craftsmen have a LONG waiting list. PM me and I can give you the names of "up and coming" leather (if that's what you want) craftsmen that have a month or less wait time.
I agree with others on the importance of a quality belt (especially carring OWB).

[frazzled]

Also of note because it is frequently forgotten, don't forget you need a nice heavy duty pistol belt. The difference between a regular belt, even a good one, and a tactical/gun belt are striking. A gun belt more even distributes the weight increasing comfort greatly. There are several, including the one I use-Beltman. Also a spare magazine is suggested with the mantra, always bring twice as much as you think you'll need.

I second the Comp-tac. I use that and a simple slider holster depending on clothing.

[DONT TREAD ON ME]

look for a post by wildscar. He has a GREAT review of the Comp-Tac Minataur M-Tac holster in his signature.
When I carry my XD I use that holster and absolutely love it!

[A-R]

+1 on gunbelts ... Awaiting my second Beltman. Also found a great nylon web belt - the 5.11 "trainer" belt 1.5 inch thickness. Very stiff and works great for times when your belt is not visible (cover garment etc).

[cdc101]

Well, I got a Fobus Rotoholster for my XD, and I'm not happy with it. Lesson learned - adjustable paddle holsters are inadequate most CC situations because the pistol simply hangs out too far..

I'm now looking at Don Hume and Uncle Mike's.

Crossbreed Supertuck - FTW (For The Win)!!!

In all seriousness, I have 3 of them (1 for each - M&P 40, Sig P-220, and XD-45 Service). I was lucky enough to choose the perfect holster(s) (for me) the first time out...thanks to the helpful people here.

Worth it worth it worth it!