hirundo82 wrote: I was simply trying to refute your assertion that open carry will automatically get you handcuffed and hauled off to jail in Virginia. I was not trying to describe where one can and cannot open carry in Virginia; if the thread had been "I'm going to Virginia, where can I open carry," I would have mentioned that it is cuurently not allowed in state parks.
Actually, the thread was about a guy taking a motorcycle trip through several states, VA among them, who wanted some info/advice as to where and how he could legally carry in some of the states on his route.
So telling him he can open carry here or there without providing all of the relavant details cold have gotten him into trouble.
hirundo82 wrote: I do not wish to get into another debate about open carry. I was simply pointing out that people in Virginia open carry every day without problem. Open carry is considered a right in many places and, like any right, could go away if not exercised.
I agree that rights can and will go away if not exercised.
And while people may well open carry in VA "every day", I have visited VA several times, and I challenge you to show me any urban area in VA where even 1% of the adults on the street are carrying openly. I know of no such place. That tells me that carrying openly in VA might well be considered a right, but it is also considered a bit unusual, to say the least.
hirundo82 wrote: I realize that you come from a state where carrying a gun is something shameful and needs to be hidden, as is the case in Texas as well, but that is not the case in every state. I see it as a way, where legal, to educate people that ordinary, law-abiding citizens carry firearms in the course of their daily lives and no problems occur.
My objections to open carry have nothing to do with "shame". I simply see it as a very bad tactical choice. Cops do it because they are in uniform and they more or less have to. They get training in weapon retention methods, they use retention holsters, and they accept the added risk, whether when mingling with crowds of strangers or in the situations that come up where they are forced to grapple with people when taking them into custody.
There is no rational reason for someone to subject themselves to that added risk when they don't have to.
Most people who carry a gun will tell you that they do so to
enhance their personal security. That's why I do it. I certainly don't do it to
add to my level of risk.
1talltxn is headed out on a bike trip, not a mission to educate people along his route that they have a right to carry openly.
hirundo82 wrote: And your insinuation that I am trying to "play cowboy" by exercising my right to open carry when it is legal is quite frankly insulting. It sounds like the rhetoric the anti-gun forces use when describing CHL holders as "Rambo" or wanting to play hero.
Open carry is a very poor tactical choice. I was merely speculating as to what might motivate someone to do it. You say, "education" is the motivator in your case. OK. I'll take your word for it.
hirundo82 wrote: I do use a retention holster when open carrying, ...
Good. I find that type of holster a bit bulkier than a concealment type, and thus harder to cover with a garment. So if someone were travelling, and wanted to sometimes open carry and sometimes to carry concealed, they would need to take a couple of different holsters along if they wanted to do it right.
hirundo82 wrote: ...and I find that it forces me to be more alert.
Yes. Exactly how someone would prefer to spend a motorcycle tour, or a walk to the local quickie mart, constantly on the alert about the gun they are openly carrying.
hirundo82 wrote: However, I have never seen any evidence (not speculation) that open carry will make an ordinary person a target of a gun grab or the first person shot in a robbery.
I've seen no stats on "ordinary people" either. That could be either because they are so formidable that no BG or group of BG's would ever think of taking a crack at them, or it could be because so few people carry openly in urban areas that there are not many opportunities for such things to occur.
You tell me.
But check out the stats on how many cops are shot each year with their own (openly carried) guns. One memorable case was a year or two ago where a female deputy in GA was whacked in a courthouse by a prisoner she was transporting. She stupidly gets in an elevator with a guy twice her size who was up on a murder charge. He takes her gun, shoots her, and shoots a few other people and makes good his (temporary) escape if I remember correctly.
Of course with cops it's a little different in that a BG would know that they were carrying whether they were carrying openly or not - because carrying is just what they do. So even if the cops carried concealed it wouldn't make any difference.
But for non-cops, no one knows whether you're carrying or not if you are carrying concealed. So there's nothing to grab. There's nothing to make them consider shooting you first. etc.
In other words, you maintain tactical surprise. To me that is a big advantage that I would not advise people to give up.