Search found 2 matches

by txinvestigator
Sat Dec 16, 2006 12:07 pm
Forum: Never Again!!
Topic: Home defense - "may very well have been justified"
Replies: 29
Views: 6551

KBCraig wrote:
txinvestigator wrote:In Texas that would guarantee Cegon a trip to the Pen.
I doubt it.

The BG was on the floor with the pistol he was carrying when he broke into the home and smashed down the bedroom door; he was alive and alert enough to speak, and could certainly be perceived as a continued threat.

Cegon said "I didn't want him to get up again." I wouldn't either. His very recent history demonstrated his intent and ability to kill everyone in the house. Were it me, I'd do as Cegon did: shoot until he was completely incapacitated.

I'd be very surprised if 99% of Texas DAs would push for an indictment in an identical shooting. I'd be even more surprised if a jury would convict. If there's ever been a clear case of "He needed killin', yer honor!", this was it.

Kevin
Nope, he dropped the gun.
A loaded gun fell from his hand.
Deadly force is NOT justified base don what someone "might" do in some future encounter.

Do the words 'immediately necessery" ring a bell?

The guy was shot, laying on the floor, with no weapon. He even had time to speak. Cegon executed him with a coup de grace.

"he needed killin" is not a justification. The criminal justice system is in place for a reason, and our laws are to allow us to defend ourselves. It does not allow us to murder people who are evil, done evil things or might come back and do evil things again.

Were I a DA I would ask for an indictment. I imagine most DA's would follow the law and do the same.
by txinvestigator
Fri Dec 15, 2006 6:41 pm
Forum: Never Again!!
Topic: Home defense - "may very well have been justified"
Replies: 29
Views: 6551

KBCraig wrote:From the article:

"You killed me," the couple recall Richter saying.

Cegon squeezed the trigger again.

"I shot him again to make sure he didn't get up," Cegon said.


I like it: "You killed me!" "Well, maybe, but just in case I didn't... " *boom*
In Texas that would guarantee Cegon a trip to the Pen.

Return to “Home defense - "may very well have been justified"”