Your logic is correct, and most TSA folks I've met either understand leaving the tag outside the case is the most reasonable thing to do, or they catch on when I point out that a reinspection would require physical destruction of the case lock to verify that it had been declared. The good thing is, even if the tag is put in the case, the bag is almost never reinspected because of the symbol placed on the destination tag, so in practical terms it doesn't matter much unless something unusual happens.kidder014 wrote:I did have everything locked in the manner you specified above. The one thing I wanted to mention was that the TSA agents at both airports insisted on the declaration tag being inside the locked case with the gun. I personally thought this was stupid, and it would make a lot more sense for it to be on the outside of the case, since obviously i'm the only one with the key to that case, and if it was inside the case they wouldn't be able to verify it had been declared, but regardless, I was specifically told by the agent at DFW that it was to be inside locked up with the gun.Excaliber wrote:Another thing to remember is that the metal box you lock the gun in should have a key that only you retain (not a TSA bypassable lock) and the luggage it's contained in should have the TSA lock on it. That way, if the bag is opened again after the initial inspection, it can be done without cutting off a lock and there is no direct access to the gun. The firearms declaration tag should be placed inside the bag on the outside of the metal storage box to show the gun has been declared.
Long story short, I really don't think there are any specific rules regarding this process. CHL holders seem to understand one set of rules, the ticket takers understand another set of rules, and every TSA agent has his own interpretation of the rules as well. Doesn't matter to me, as long as my firearm makes it where it needs to be and I don't end up in handcuffs...
Ticket agents appear to have very little training in this area, and you need to be vigilant and insist that the procedures you know are required are followed. If they're not, you're the one in trouble, not them. I make sure I know all the ins and outs, and ask for a supervisor at the first sign of uncertainty.