Search found 15 matches

by mr surveyor
Fri Jan 10, 2014 9:41 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

doc540 wrote:Got mine back and the trigger was just ruined.

spongy, 8lbs, and didn't break until it almost touched the back of the trigger guard

Rather than try to send it back to SA, I sold it. :grumble
exactly my experience ... rather than trade, or buy another gun with the proceeds (which usually ends up in another disaster), I bought a new chronograph, replaced a digital scale, bought a few reloading components, and gave the wife a "Christmas bonus". I think that will probably be my last "plastic fantastic".

JD
by mr surveyor
Sat Nov 02, 2013 10:10 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

Shoot_First wrote:
RogueUSMC wrote:
Shoot_First wrote:
RogueUSMC wrote:
Shoot_First wrote:My XDs .45 came home from...and the slide may be just a tad bit wider...
??
Perhaps it is because of the new slide mounted safety. :evil2:
lol...you ain't right dude...
You ain't the first to say that. Perhaps because I'm rogue US Army Retired after over 31 years of active duty. My initial post after I got my XDs ,45 back from SA was all in jest after having read on the XD Talk forum about how much different the XDs was post "upgrade." I put about 120 rounds through my fixed XDs ,45 today and find it to be substantially as before I sent it off to SA... the trigger pull seems just a bit higher than before but smooth with no over travel.

funny you should mention the "other forum". I always make it a point to register of a brand specific forum if I own any model of that brand, just in case I want to post a question. In the case of that particular "other forum", you have to be a registered member to access pictures. I bought my XDs a couple of weeks before the recall was announced and wanted to see the pic's in the "how to" threads, so I registered to have access to the "knowledge" but hadn't really had time to really put my new XDs through the wringer before the recall (actually caught wind of the recall on a totally separate forum the night it was announced on the 28th, and shipped mine on the morning of the 29th). Then I started following the chatter on the XDs sub forum. Wow, what entertainment :lol: ! Kinda reminds me of the 4th grade.

Even though my XDs didn't come back with the upgrade slide from a Hi-Point, the trigger ended up at 8.8, which is a bit much .... I suppose I could take the time to slick up the sear and striker, and may do that if I ever get the time to even care. Even though this one was intended to eventually get into the carry mode, I had/have plenty of "carry guns" already so this one ain't gonna ruin my life if I decide I just don't like it (or it don't like me).

By the way, did you also get the $25 dollar discount coupon for the 50 round drum magazine?


JD
by mr surveyor
Wed Oct 23, 2013 5:59 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

The Annoyed Man wrote:
mr surveyor wrote:just got mine back
How long did it take?
shipped out on Aug 29, delivered to SA the morning of Sept 3, showed as "fixed" last Friday afternoon, and got the shipping notice this Monday.

As has been described many times on other forums (particularly the "XD Forum"), even though I shipped it wrapped in bubble wrap in a plain box mine was returned in a "used" small generic black plastic SA case in addition to the promised 7 round extended mag (with both small and large grip extensions). Nice touch.

I did take a few minutes to handle it a bit before getting back to my work duties. The gun was just as clean as it was when I sent it in after a good cleaning (had less than a couple hundred rounds through it in the two weeks I actually "had possession"). A little dry firing gave me a feel for what to expect with live fire, although having so few rounds through it some seven weeks ago I don't really have a good gauge to compare the "before and after". It does seem to have a tiny bit more slack "take up", but a bit shorter (maybe a tiny bit heavier?) engagement .... with a very nice sharp break. Since I didn't have it long enough to develop a real feel for it, the whole experience with the XDs for me will be new.

Personally, although I've owned quite a few, I'm not a big fan of the "plastic fantastics". This was just one of a very few I had to try, and I do think it will fit a niche for me.


JD
by mr surveyor
Wed Oct 23, 2013 3:55 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

just got mine back
by mr surveyor
Tue Oct 22, 2013 12:49 am
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

my status went to "Your Gun has been sent back to you" sometime tonight (Monday night)
by mr surveyor
Tue Oct 22, 2013 12:02 am
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

I'm guessing that the first day's deliveries on 09/03 just went into a big pile (by date received) and they were logged in for repair at random from that pile. Probably the same for each day's receipts, or possibly they even let 2-3 days worth pile up before randomly processing from the batch.

I bet you'll see a change in status pretty soon.
by mr surveyor
Mon Oct 21, 2013 11:49 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

Teamless wrote:I Havent received anything from SA yet on the return of mine.


have you checked the website for the status? Mine changed to "fixed" on Friday afternoon and the email for shipping notice came today at 5:00 p.m.
by mr surveyor
Mon Oct 21, 2013 8:42 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

mr surveyor wrote:got my tracking number this afternoon ... return delivery slated for Wednesday

just in case I wasn't totally clear .... the tracking number is for the trip FROM Illinois, and the Wednesday delivery is TO downtown Stumpwater, Texas :cool:
by mr surveyor
Mon Oct 21, 2013 5:55 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

got my tracking number this afternoon ... return delivery slated for Wednesday
by mr surveyor
Sat Oct 19, 2013 10:59 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

ChillMickelson wrote:I'm just not impressed with them calling the fatal flaw fix an "upgrade."

Bad PR

and just what is the "fatal flaw"?

this recall has become downright silly with all the "sky is falling" chatter, and my guess is that most of the whiners either have very little experience with firearms in general or have no "skin in the game" to begin with.

Even if I'm not satisfied with my XDs when I get it back next week, I'm sure that the sun will come up the next day if God so chooses. Springfield acknowledged a potential problem (actually a problem most likely due to having to make this model idiot proof) and spent millions of dollars to address the issue (in reality probably a non-issue).

The only "modern" Springfield firearm I own (or have ever owned) is the XDs I purchased in mid August that I should get back next week, so I'm not the stereotypical brand-x fanboy. Just an old codger that doesn't like to see unnecessary bashing of a company trying to do the right thing.

JD
by mr surveyor
Tue Oct 01, 2013 7:13 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

joshv53 wrote:I was in the market for an xds 45 before the recall occurred. Can I still order a new one or has production also been shut down? Also it says a certain set of serial numbers were affected. Was it essentially ever xds ever made or just newer or older productions?


I believe you will find that it's every XDs.

There are still XDs pistols on the shelves of a few shops that I know of. The shop owners have money invested in them, and SA isn't going to give them a refund anymore than they are going to give me a refund until they (SA) cry uncle over the current "issue" (whether it's truly warranted or not). I'm not even going to speculate on the final outcome. If they decide they have a fix for it, that's fine ... I was looking for a "non-safety lever", slim .45 acp when I bought the XDs. For me, it was between the XDs and the Kahr (I do like my Kahr pistols), but the C series Kahr 45's seem to be plagued with magazine issues that I just didn't want to spend the time to work out. If SA does give it up and offers a refund, I'll put half the money into doing some refurb work on my Kimber and the other half on a good airgun (the last thing on my current bucket list).

I'm not in a bind, and am patient enough to give them a couple of months to come up with a reasonable solution.


JD
by mr surveyor
Thu Sep 26, 2013 11:28 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

LTUME1978 wrote:Whining??? Lets see, you buy two new cars and you have not even had a chance to drive one of them. The dealership calls you and tells you that they recommend that you bring them in for a recall (voluntary, not mandatory) even though your cars seem to be ok and don't exhibit any problems they describe. They tell you that you will have them back in 30 days :-(. Now, you have to drive 1.5 hours to take the cars in to the dealer and take a day of vacation to do that (put a price on that). A week after they get to the dealer, the dealer tells you that it will now be 10-12 weeks before you get your cars back and that they are just now figuring out how to fix your cars so you realize that it may be longer than 12 weeks and the fix may not be the final fix. You ask to get your car back from the dealer until they get things figured out and can turn it around quickly and they tell you no, you can't have your property back (remember the voluntary part?). In Texas, you start lemon law proceedings and get your money back on your car. In the case of our pistols, we have our money tied up for a long time with nothing to shoot and a less than warm feeling that they have a final solution to the problem, and we have no recourse to drive a quick solution to the problem.

Since you think it is whining, please let me hold on to two of your newest pistols until I get mine back and we will see how that goes for you.

In case you're wondering, and I'm sure it doesn't make any difference, My 2 week old XDs was shipped to Springfield on Aug 29, the morning after the recall was announced. So, yes, I DO have skin in the game. A potential safety issue was brought to light, Springfield put some thought into the issue, and decided to spend several million dollars on parts upgrades for 250,000+ pistols in a voluntary recall. For what it's worth, I only put a couple hundred rounds through my XDs before the recall ..... and, funny thing, it never slam fired, nor did it go full auto, nor did it magically sneak out of my house and shoot anyone while I wasn't looking.

I can understand those that bought the XDs as their first handgun being upset over the issue .... I've had a few guns myself that went back to the mothership in my lifetime. But, when the manufacturer is paying shipping, both ways, and doing a safety upgrade for the benefit of the user and the public in general, why do some feel like Springfield owes them some kind of extra goodie bag.

As for me, and any prior/current relationship with Springfield ..... I've only owned one other firearm (still have it) with the Springfield label on it - an 1872 Rolling Block rifle, in .50-70 Government (actually manufactured by Remington). So, no, I don't "work" for Springfield.

JD
by mr surveyor
Thu Sep 26, 2013 8:35 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

well, I won't be happy with anything less than the return of a 100% pistol, lifetime guarantee, free night sights, free trigger job, 3 free magazines, a Springfield cap and a new set of tires for my truck ;-)

I can't believe all the whining.
by mr surveyor
Wed Sep 25, 2013 10:01 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

no real problem to me, just a minor bump in life. I sold a gun that rarely got carried and bought the XDs that I barely had a chance to shoot before shipping it out. We'll see what happens in another 5-6 weeks. Nothing to get all worked up over ..... yet
by mr surveyor
Thu Aug 29, 2013 2:31 pm
Forum: General Gun, Shooting & Equipment Discussion
Topic: Urgent: XDs recall...
Replies: 368
Views: 64754

Re: Urgent: XDs recall...

got my shipping label last night and took it to the shipping center in Longview this morning. I asked the clerk how many she had seen today and she said not a single firearm. I started to not even worry about the recall, but with some 186k units in the recall I figured to go ahead and ship in the first early wave in case I changed my mind to not ignore the situation next month.

I still wonder if there really was a design flaw that absolutely needed to be addressed, or if all the hype over safety issues from a very small number of the XDs line could have just been a few lemons that slipped through with manufacturing flaws. Either way, Springfield is doing good PR in taking some type of action.


surv

Return to “Urgent: XDs recall...”