Rex B wrote:Buy a nice 10/22, and a Youth stock from Brownells.
Give it to her with the youth stock installed. When she outgrows it, install the original stock.
Then get the 2nd daughter a new 10/22, and install the youth stock.
Rinse repeat.
I've spent a few years and way too much mental energy on this same question.
I ended up getting my kiddos a Marlin 795 to share.
I was looking at the Savage, the Cricket, the Ruger, the Marlin 60, and the Smith & Wesson 10/22.
The Marlin 795 is less expensive than the Ruger and most reviewers felt it was much more accurate and had a far superior barrel out of the box. The Ruger has infinitely more accessories and after market parts available, but a lot of folks talked about the trap of ending up with a $400-500 Ruger before they were done with changing stuff out. The only high capacity mag available for the Marlin seems to be junk, so I'm sticking with the OEM 10 rounders for now.
I haven't shot it yet, but I'm looking forward to getting out soon. We got the synthetic stock version at Academy. My kids are younger than OPs, so it's a little heavy for them, but I'll start them at a bench and just go over safety, range etiquette, and firearm basics. I like the ability to load 1 shot now but move to semi-auto as they learn and grow.
I finally decided not to get each kid their own .22LR (we've got four kids with #5 on the way!). I'd rather have one "family" .22 that we teach and plink with, then see as they get older where their interests direct them. . .
In .22's, the nice thing is you can't really go wrong. Sounds like good family fun no matter what you decide!