Pistol vs. revolver

[LDB415]

You get a new pistol. You run at least several mags full of ammo, from every magazine you'll carry, through to confirm proper functioning and readiness just in case.

How many rounds do you need to run through a new revolver to confirm proper functioning and readiness?

[JCole]

I think a box of my preferred carry ammo is sufficient in a new revolver, just to weed out light primer strikes, firing pin issues, etc. Although, truth be told, 12 rounds is probably enough.

[68Charger]

This is a very good question. The only malfunction I can foresee is firing pin issues, timing issues and.. well.. I think that's it?

I would like to hear someone with revolver experience to chime in on this.

How many rounds do you consider it is ready to go?

[LDB415]

Yes, I hope folks with experience and opinions on revolvers will chime in.

[myntalfloss]

You get a new pistol. You run at least several mags full of ammo, from every magazine you'll carry, through to confirm proper functioning and readiness just in case.

How many rounds do you need to run through a new revolver to confirm proper functioning and readiness?

Fifty.

One to check the firing pin, one to make sure that the cylinder is indexing properly.

The other 48 to calibrate your funometer.

[thatguy]

If it's a carry gun my "number" is at least 500 rounds, bare minimum. I don't start feeling warm and fuzzy until about 3000 rounds.

That being said, I've seen numerous revolvers malfunction on this gun range. Some new, some old, bad ammo etc... But a malfunction just the same.

Just one man's opinion.

[rotor]

My S&W 19-4 had issues with certain primers. On my reloads Federal and Remington worked great but CCI and Winchester did not. I found that I needed to tighten the main spring adjusting screw ( which took less than 5 minutes to do but required Google and YouTube to guide me). So, revolvers can have problems too and can be ammo sensitive. I don't know if the big ammo companies use the same primer brands each time so even knowing that one ammo brand works is no guarantee that it will always work. On the other hand I like revolvers better than pistols because I reload and I don't like picking up brass

[LDB415]

If it's a carry gun my "number" is at least 500 rounds, bare minimum. I don't start feeling warm and fuzzy until about 3000 rounds.

That being said, I've seen numerous revolvers malfunction on this gun range. Some new, some old, bad ammo etc... But a malfunction just the same.

Just one man's opinion.

Are you saying 500 through a revolver or a pistol? And how many through the other one?

[Barron76]

I always go around 500 rounds thru my carry pistols... never really thought about revolvers though. I would use several different brands of ammo to see how picky the gun was and to make sure she functions the way I want & going thru that process would probably take me at least 300-400 rounds.

[thatguy]

How many rounds do you need to run through a new revolver to confirm proper functioning and readiness?

However many it takes for you to feel confident that you can trust it.

I ran literally thousands of rounds of ammo through my 1911 to see what worked and what didn't (the only one that didn't - unless I really tweaked the OAL - was the overly-long Lee cast 200gr SWC). For a revolver, I'd be slightly less-picky.

What he said...