Moderator: carlson1
mine now shows the sameShoot_First wrote:ATDM, Teamless, & Irpettit: My status just changed to "Your gun has been fixed." How about yours?
you know, we go this Sunday to PSC, we may have to go next Sunday also!NordicTexan wrote:I got mine back today. FedEx tried to deliver it at 2:30 so I called and picked it up at the local office. Nice to have it back.
The trigger, during dry fire is slightly firmer than before. I am looking forward to going with teamless this weekend to break it in, again.
Oh they sent it back in a small black carring case, which had a sticker for an XD sc 40. Gave me a pause when I thought they may have sent the wrong gun to me. My xds with the extra mag was in there so I am happy again.
That's very interesting.ATDM wrote:New status
That was just a joke...jmra wrote:That's very interesting.ATDM wrote:New status
That was my assumption, but it was kinda like asking a woman with a bulging tummy if she's pregnant. You're pretty sure she is, but...ATDM wrote:That was just a joke...jmra wrote:That's very interesting.ATDM wrote:New status
Or, they have sent our to Croatia, but they ended up in Serbia...Shoot_First wrote:Teamless, ATDM, and Shoot-First must be on the bottom of the Sep 3 stack!
As to Denny’s claim that the XD-S shoots better, I agree. The groups you see here in the pictures were the best examples I took from over 200 rounds in each gun. Most of my shooting was with range rounds, mostly milsurp and Speer Lawman. Both my rested and offhand groups were smaller with the upgraded guns. They weren’t drastically different, especially offhand, but as a whole the upgraded groups were smaller, with much fewer flier shots. The targets I picked for the pictures were shot with Hornady Critical Defense, which has always been my best performer in the XD-S.
When you get your gun back, don’t be surprised if you don’t feel that the trigger pull is heavier than when the gun left, even though it technically will be. I had to put my digital trigger gauge on the upgraded guns, because side by side I felt that the difference wasn’t something you would notice. The gauge measured slightly over ½ a pound difference. So far I have blind tested five people to dry fire both the orignal and upgraded guns, and none so far have been able to tell any difference in the pull.
As a side note, because so many discussion board “experts” skip over this. a heavier trigger pull isn’t the worst thing when talking about striker fired guns. Everyone’s biggest complaint on striker guns is that the trigger is too light, when compared to a double action/single action semi-automatic or a double action revolver. Some worry that a light trigger results in accidental discharges, though in practice they are infrequent. The XD-S upgrade only adds about a ½ a pound of trigger pull to the gun, and I think the trigger is a little smoother. The upgrade also does not effect the reset length, which is just over 1/10th of an inch on the XD-S. Side by side, besides the trigger pull, the only physical difference I could ascertain was that the grip safety seems to allow the trigger to fire a little bit earlier.
Interestingly, I've never heard that as a complaint of DAO guns before. Learn something new every dayAs a side note, because so many discussion board “experts” skip over this. a heavier trigger pull isn’t the worst thing when talking about striker fired guns. Everyone’s biggest complaint on striker guns is that the trigger is too light, when compared to a double action/single action semi-automatic or a double action revolver.
Yeah, I thought that "Everyone's" description was a little broad. When I first started carrying with my CHL, I carried a cocked and locked Sig 1911. Hard to imagine a striker trigger getting lighter and crisper than that.Cedar Park Dad wrote:Interestingly, I've never heard that as a complaint of DAO guns before. Learn something new every dayAs a side note, because so many discussion board “experts” skip over this. a heavier trigger pull isn’t the worst thing when talking about striker fired guns. Everyone’s biggest complaint on striker guns is that the trigger is too light, when compared to a double action/single action semi-automatic or a double action revolver.
It shoots better, because it's a bi-tone...The Annoyed Man wrote:[ Image ]
Upgraded gun on the right; non-upgraded gun on the left. Gun on the right shoots better.
I don't know if he was specifically addressing the XD family of guns or striker guns in general. If the former, then it wasn't a complaint about DAO guns which may explain why you haven't heard that complaint before.Cedar Park Dad wrote:Interestingly, I've never heard that as a complaint of DAO guns before. Learn something new every dayAs a side note, because so many discussion board “experts” skip over this. a heavier trigger pull isn’t the worst thing when talking about striker fired guns. Everyone’s biggest complaint on striker guns is that the trigger is too light, when compared to a double action/single action semi-automatic or a double action revolver.
